Log in

No account? Create an account
Bill Roper's Journal
Me vs. The Compiler 
30th-Mar-2017 11:49 pm
I figured out the source of yesterday's problem.

I had put in a forward definition for a class in a header file so that I could declare a pointer to an object of that type inside the class that was defined in the header file. Like this:

class AnotherClass;

class ThisClass
  AnotherClass*   anotherClassInstance;

When I destroy ThisClass, I want to destroy the instance of AnotherClass that it contains. No problem. I'll just call delete on the pointer like this:

delete anotherClassInstance;

That should work just fine.

Except it didn't. Because I hadn't actually included the header file for AnotherClass in the .cpp file for ThisClass. What I would have expected was that this should have produced a compile error telling me that I was operating on a class that hadn't been completely defined.

But there was no compile error. Instead, the Visual Studio compiler just called delete on anotherClassInstance like it was a pointer to a random chunk of memory with no destructor.

Hilarity ensued.

Well, at least I should remember what caused me to waste so much time the next time I run into this problem...

31st-Mar-2017 01:29 pm (UTC)
A compiler that assumes at run time such things would be properly in place? Never!
31st-Mar-2017 03:53 pm (UTC)
Who knows? Maybe it's been fixed in a later version of Visual Studio. But I'm still mired on VS2010, because one of our programmers decided that the best thing to do for his particular project was to use a bunch of undocumented methods that are not in later versions of the libraries.


So now we have to fix all of his code before we can migrate forward.
This page was loaded May 25th 2018, 9:03 am GMT.