Bill Roper (billroper) wrote,
Bill Roper

I Hate This

Ok, by now you've all heard that NASA has canceled the Hubble servicing mission that was planned for the next couple of years, which means that the Hubble will fail before the next space telescope is launched. And I want to be really, really ticked off about it, because I find the information that we're getting back from the Hubble to be absolutely fascinating.

And I would be, if I didn't see exactly the chain of logic involved in canceling the flight. If the goal is to establish a permanent human presence in space -- a goal which I agree with, although I'm sure that some of you don't -- then you have to look at the things that will prevent you from achieving that. And number one on that list is: another catastrophic failure of a Shuttle with loss of all hands.

Apparently, the only planned Shuttle mission that doesn't have the delta-V to rendezvous with the ISS in case of tile loss is the Hubble servicing mission. Thus, the only mission where you couldn't use the ISS as a lifeboat and repair station is the Hubble mission. So rather than continue to spend time and effort trying to figure out how to repair a Shuttle in orbit away from the ISS, you can redeploy those efforts to -- for instance -- trying to build a better vehicle to replace the aging Shuttle fleet.

All you have to do is be willing to give up the Hubble Space Telescope sooner than you would have otherwise. It makes perfect sense.

It doesn't mean I have to like it.
Tags: musings, space

  • Steps

    Today is better than yesterday. Still short on solutions, but maybe I can get some time to sort things out. Thanks, folks.

  • Well, That Escalated Quickly

    Today could have been better. Much better.

  • The More You Know

    The problem with getting older is that -- although you may know more than you did when you were younger -- it seems like there are more and more…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment