Bill Roper (billroper) wrote,
Bill Roper
billroper

The Current Labor Shortage

Yesterday's post on immigration actually triggered more response than I thought that it would. And the discussion that followed moves me to ask a question about the two statements below:

1) Illegal immigrants fill jobs that Americans aren't willing to do.

2) The H-1B visa program allows industry to recruit technical workers, because there is a shortage of them in the U.S.

Now, I know that there are apparently qualified technical workers among my friends who've found it difficult to get a job following the dotcom bust, at the same time that industry is arguing that they need more H-1B workers. And I -- and others -- have wondered if it's simply a case of industry wanting more workers who will accept substandard wages and who dare not complain lest they be sent back to their home country.

If I have the strong suspicion that statement 2 is a crock, why should I believe something different about statement 1?

So what do you think? Is either statement true?
Tags: musings, politics
Subscribe

  • Swimming Upstream

    There are too many things being recalcitrant right now. Eventually, there will be a breakthrough, but this was apparently not the day for it. Let's…

  • We'll Just Keep Counting Down to Zero

    We got far less accomplished than we might have hoped this weekend. On the other hand, I think we're collectively in a better mood, so I'm going to…

  • Wiring It Up

    We are now in the final phases of the kitchen renovation. There's a small bit of trim and some spackling and touch up painting that needs to be done…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 25 comments

  • Swimming Upstream

    There are too many things being recalcitrant right now. Eventually, there will be a breakthrough, but this was apparently not the day for it. Let's…

  • We'll Just Keep Counting Down to Zero

    We got far less accomplished than we might have hoped this weekend. On the other hand, I think we're collectively in a better mood, so I'm going to…

  • Wiring It Up

    We are now in the final phases of the kitchen renovation. There's a small bit of trim and some spackling and touch up painting that needs to be done…